NGI The Weekly Gas Market Report / NGI All News Access

SoCalEdison Hit with Securities Fraud Suit

SoCalEdison Hit with Securities Fraud Suit

Rosemead, CA-based Edison International and its Southern California Edison utility were hit with a $2.4 billion securities fraud class action federal lawsuit last Monday, alleging the companies' violated parts of the federal securities law by booking as revenue in the second and third quarters more than $2.3 billion in summer wholesale power costs that have yet to be collected.

Edison said it was still reviewing the suit, and declined to comment at this time. The other major California power utility, Pacific Gas and Electric, San Francisco, has not been targeted by a similar lawsuit, although it, like Edison, did not take any write-offs for the pending under-collections.

The legal action was filed by a Huntington Beach, CA, lawyer, Douglas A. Ames, who maintains that he has "extensive experience litigating against Edison." Last year, Ames said he won a $6.35 million jury verdict against the Edison utility on behalf of an energy efficiency company, Transphase Systems, which alleged that the multi-billion-dollar utility had "maliciously driven" them out of business.

In the latest case, Ames on behalf of one former Edison shareholder "representing a class" alleged that the utility and its parent company essentially is "booking phantom revenue" in its handling of the under-collections and that "grossly deviates" from Generally Accepted Accounting Practices (GAAP) and applicable Financial Accounting Standards.

"It is money Edison hasn't billed --- that isn't even billable --- yet it is accounting for this money like it was in its bank account," said Ames, who added that based on last Friday's pre-hearing conference at the California Public Utilities Commission on the issue there is no indication the state regulators are going to act soon to allow Edison to recover the charges.

He argued the "the uncertainty is borne by Edison management" to report the company's financial statements in accordance with GAAP and financial accounting standards. Even in Edison International's recent 8-K filing with the Securities Exchange Commission, the company stated that the standard involved in this issue is whether it is "probable" that it will recover the entire $2.358 billion in order to record it as revenue, Ames said.

Ames said he is not emphasizing the $2.4 billion value of his lawsuit because it is based on some complex financial calculations, attempting to determine how badly Edison's stock price would be hurt by an accounting for the current under-collections in full.

"It was based on looking at the average trading volume and an assumption that the dollar value would go down by about $8/share."

Richard Nemec, Los Angeles

©Copyright 2000 Intelligence Press, Inc. All rights reserved. The preceding news report may not be republished or redistributed in whole or in part without prior written consent of Intelligence Press, Inc.