Natural gas futures crumbled further on Monday as weather models continued to warm, perhaps even a bit too much. With production above 100 Bcf/d and Freeport LNG still offline, the January Nymex gas futures contract settled at $5.577/MMBtu, down a jaw-dropping 70.4 cents from Friday’s close. February futures slid 68.5 cents to $5.484.


At A Glance:

  • More warmth seen in forecasts
  • Storage surplus seen again
  • Permian cash prices negative

Spot gas prices also tumbled everywhere except the West amid higher-than-normal temperatures, along with pipeline maintenance in the Permian Basin. NGI’s Spot Gas National Avg. dropped 30.0 cents to $5.855.

After warming late last week, weather models sapped even more demand from the 15-day outlook. The Global Forecast System (GFS) trended a massive 23 heating degree days (HDD) warmer over the weekend, while the European model shed 10 HDDs.

NatGasWeather said both data sets were “quite bearish” overall through Dec. 15. This is largely because of warmer-than-normal temperatures covering the southern and eastern United States on most days. That said, the forecaster noted that the GFS is nearly 20 HDDs warmer than the European model for the coming 15 days, which would likely lead to a revision one way or the other.

The weekend weather data teased a colder pattern finally setting up Dec. 16-20, but there have been multiple instances in recent weeks where the data was cold and then shifted warmer. As such, the natural gas markets didn’t give the frostier forecast much credence on Monday.

NatGasWeather said frigid air over Canada is expected to dive into the Pacific Northwest and Northern Plains/Midwest going forward. However, the weather data failed to advance it eastward, instead favoring the warm ridge over the southern and eastern United States to effectively block the cold air from advancing out of the Midwest through the middle of the month.

“There will be potential for cold air to eventually spread across the northern and eastern U.S.; it just won’t be until after Dec. 15,” NatGasWeather said.

With warmer weather in place beginning last week, the reduction in gas demand for heating is likely to stall the string of hefty storage withdrawals the market has seen the past couple of weeks.

Preliminary withdrawal estimates for the upcoming Energy Information Administration (EIA) inventory were ranging widely on Monday, from a draw as light as 15 Bcf to one as stout as 56 Bcf for the week ending Dec. 2. NGI projected a 25 Bcf pull.

Last week, the EIA reported a larger-than-normal 81 Bcf withdrawal from stocks for the week ending Nov. 28. The draw left inventories 89 Bcf below year-earlier levels and 86 Bcf below the five-year average.

However, given the mild weather outlook this month, NatGasWeather said stocks could flip back to a surplus over the five-year average after the next three EIA reports are accounted for. “If cold fails to arrive for Dec. 17-30, surpluses will increase further.”

Although it appears much of the Lower 48 may be sporting summer attire for a couple more weeks, EBW Analytics Group LLC said the first week of December remained far too early to call winter finished. After all, the market is still awaiting the return of liquefied natural gas exports from Freeport LNG. Two carriers were reportedly anchored off the Texas coast.

Intake volumes at other LNG export facilities also have fluctuated over the past week. NGI data showed feed gas deliveries back at 12.17 Dth on Monday, up from weekend lows but still off from a peak of 12.97 Dthlast week.

No doubt, LNG demand is poised to climb in the coming weeks as frigid weather that has finally arrived in Europe is likely to keep the call high on U.S. LNG.

Maxar’s Weather Desk (MWD) said the coming week would feature widespread below-normal temperatures across the UK, France, Germany, southern Norway and southern Sweden. The chilly outlook is set to occur as an upper level trough sweeps across northwestern Europe.

The bitter conditions are expected to linger through the six- to 10-day period as well, according to MWD forecasters. Germany and Poland may be particularly cold as upper level troughing generates below-normal readings in the UK, France as well as western and central Scandinavia. MWD also projected rough seas in the Northeast Atlantic amid an unsettled weather pattern throughout the week.

Back in the Lower 48, EBW said forecaster DTN has reiterated its call for a transition to a cold mid- to late December, potentially offering bullish hope and avoiding a full collapse in Nymex winter risk premiums.

If the more wintry forecast comes to fruition, natural gas remains on the price-inelastic portion of the demand curve and could yet regain losses, according to the firm.

“Still, momentum has turned bearish and our fair value for 1Q2023 has fallen to just $5.47/MMBtu – with late-winter weakness increasingly likely,” EBW senior energy analyst Eli Rubin said.

Big Spot Gas Declines

Most U.S. spot gas prices continued to retreat on Monday amid a balmy weather pattern and light demand.

The Northeast posted some of the biggest losses as temperatures in the region warmed to the 60s to low 80s. The accompanying drop in heating demand sent PNGTS next-day gas tumbling $1.095 from Friday to $5.080. Transco Zone 6 non-NY was down $1.200 to $3.950.

Similar price discounts extended into Appalachia, where Texas Eastern M-3, Delivery lost $1.215 to average $3.910 for Tuesday’s gas day.

Losses were capped at less than $1 across most of the country’s midsection. Defiance cash was down 81.5 cents to $4.160, while Enable East was down 34.0 cents to $3.905.

In West Texas, pipeline maintenance that was set to begin on Permian Highway Pipeline (PHP) on Tuesday sent prices crashing down into negative territory.

Kinder Morgan Inc. said PHP’s capacity would be reduced through Friday to 1.1 Bcf from 2.1 Bcf. Throughput is set to return to the normal capacity from Dec. 10-12, but is set to fall again to 1.65 Bcf from Dec. 13-16. PHP is scheduled to resume normal operations on Dec. 17, according to Kinder Morgan.

With gas flows out of the Permian limited, cash prices cratered. Waha plunged $2.945 from Friday to average only 26.5 cents for Tuesday’s delivery. The lowest price at the West Texas location was seen at negative 30.0 cents.

Meanwhile, West Coast cash prices recovered swiftly from pre-weekend lows as frigid air was in store for the region this week.

The National Weather Service said below-average temperatures are expected across areas west of the Rockies and across the Northern Plains. The greatest deviation from the norm is expected across the Northern Plains, where Arctic air is seen keeping temperatures 15-20 degrees below normal from eastern Montana, across the Dakotas and into Minnesota.

This area also may see the threat of accumulating snow, particularly early in the week. Although amounts are not expected to be heavy for the most part, northwestern Montana and northern Idaho could see more than a foot of snow.

Opal spot gas prices shot up $3.140 from Friday to average $17.105, while the SoCal Border Avg. jumped $3.880 to $18.390.