Natural gas futures sold off a few cents on Thursday as the Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported a weekly storage withdrawal that was bearish versus the five-year average, although the 15-day weather outlook remained supportive overall for a market seen as generally balanced.

Spot prices posted broad-based declines Thursday, including in the Northeast, where points moderated as another nor’easter swept through the region. The NGI National Spot Gas Average fell 12 cents to $2.54/MMBtu.

The April contract settled at $2.756 Thursday, down 2.1 cents from Wednesday’s settle. May settled 1.9 cents lower at $2.787.

Daily Markets Coverage, Analysis, & Price Data at 170+ Locations Since 1993

Thursday’s EIA storage data aligned with market expectations, and following the report prices traded in a tight range after selling off to as low as $2.737 earlier in the trading session.

EIA reported a 57 Bcf withdrawal from U.S. gas stocks for the week ending March 2, matching  the year-ago withdrawal of 57 Bcf and looser versus a five-year average pull of 129 Bcf. Last week, EIA reported a 78 Bcf withdrawal.

In the minutes following the 10:30 a.m. EDT release of the final number, the April contract hovered around $2.752, within a penny of where prices stood prior to the report. By 11 a.m. EDT, after briefly moving as high as $2.764, April was trading around $2.750, down about 2.5 cents from Wednesday’s settlement.

Prior to Thursday’s report, estimates had pointed to a withdrawal that was close to the actual figure.

A Reuters survey of traders and analysts had on average predicted a 58 Bcf withdrawal for the week. Responses had ranged from -44 Bcf to -69 Bcf. A Bloomberg survey had showed a median -58 Bcf and a range of -50 Bcf to -69 Bcf. OPIS, through its newly formed analytics division (formerly PointLogic Energy), had estimated a 61 Bcf withdrawal for the week. Stephen Smith Energy Associates had called for a 57 Bcf withdrawal. Intercontinental Exchange storage futures had settled at -58 Bcf Wednesday.

Total working gas in underground storage stood at 1,625 Bcf as of March 2, according to EIA. That’s versus 2,305 Bcf a year ago and five-year average inventories of 1,925 Bcf. The current year/year storage deficit held week/week at -680 Bcf, while the year-on-five-year deficit shrank from -372 Bcf to -300 Bcf, EIA data show.

By region, the largest withdrawal came in the East at 23 Bcf, followed by 18 Bcf withdrawn in the Midwest. The Pacific saw a 12 Bcf pull for the period, while 5 Bcf was withdrawn in the Mountain region. The South Central region finished nearly unchanged for the week, with 6 Bcf injected into salt offsetting 6 Bcf pulled from nonsalt, according to EIA.

Bespoke Weather Services attributed Thursday’s price action to “modest” overnight heating demand losses in the weather outlook “and an EIA print that hit most market expectations but indicated week/week and seasonal loosening.

“With prices having ground higher over the last few weeks off structural tightness it would appear that the market has at least found a decent balance here, and later contracts along the strip provided significant support to keep the front of the strip from dipping back below $2.75 for any significant amount of time, indicating a relative fair value at these price levels,” the firm said.

Bespoke said it expects $2.72-2.75 support to hold through the weekend “unless we lose a significant amount of heating demand on overnight guidance.”

Analysts with Societe Generale on Thursday said they’re bullish on 2018 U.S. gas prices, “although our near-term price conviction is soft given the lack of visibility around the production growth rate over the next eight months, as well as weather.”

The analysts pointed to well freeze-offs at the start of the year in key natural gas producing regions that dented “supply growth trends. In addition, we expect winter 2017/18 to result in a 2.2 Tcf draw, leaving storage at end-March at around 1.55 Tcf. This would be the second largest net storage draw since 2010/11. The storage start to the 2018 injection season...will likely be 200 Bcf below the five-year average.

“Finally, total U.S. demand should increase by approximately 6%, and growth in the liquefied natural gas (LNG) export market is a significant driver,” the Societe Generale team said. “As a result, we forecast second quarter 2018 prices at $2.89/MMBtu and third quarter 2018 at $3.00/MMBtu, both above current forward prices.”

NatGasWeather on Thursday reported “no major changes” in the latest weather data. “After one strong weather system and cold shot gradually exits the Northeast Friday, another one will arrive into the East early next week with another round of rain, snow and wind, while also advancing deeper into the Southeast with near freezing temperatures.”

After a mild period March 16-19, “the data has become solidly on board with colder systems returning across the northern and eastern U.S. March 21-25 for stronger than normal national demand as winter looks to hold on past the official end date.”

After recent cold, the next two storage reports could “come in a bit larger than the five-year, and with the 10-15 day forecast becoming cold-weighted, there’s plenty of reason for markets to use weather as an excuse to push prices higher, if they choose,” NatGasWeather said. “...We aren’t convinced bears aren’t just setting a trap, or waiting for the first signs of milder spring patterns to show up in the maps to push prices lower.”

In the spot market, moderate temperatures accompanied falling prices across most regions, while East Coast points pulled back after surging earlier in the week ahead of inclement weather that hammered the region Wednesday and Thursday.

A mid-week winter storm produced heavy winds and dropped as much as three feet of snow in parts of the Northeast, according to forecasters. Weather Underground reported Thursday that at least one person died during Winter Storm Quinn, the second nor’easter to sweep through the region over the past week, while an estimated one million customers lost power.

According to the National Weather Service, “A strong nor’easter impacting New England will lift up across the Gulf of Maine” on Thursday and then gradually weaken,” into Friday “as the center of low pressure then moves inland across interior sections of Maine…Meanwhile, the remainder of the eastern U.S. will be generally cold through the remainder of the week as a well-defined upper trough settles southeastward. High temperatures will generally be as much as 10-15 degrees below normal.”

The natural gas demand impact from the latest nor’easter appeared mixed, given the power outages and relatively moderate temperatures in population centers like Boston and New York City, where Weather Underground reported highs in the upper 30s to 40s Thursday.

The storm “could drive basis volatility, but will more likely be more demand-destructive than stimulating,” Genscape Inc. said. “...Temperature-driven demand forecasts show New England demand reaching 3.1 Bcf/d, and Appalachia demand reaching 15.5 Bcf/d, the highest levels since mid-February. Heating degree days are expected to average 29.9 for the next week, hovering right around the seasonal average.

“The proximity of this storm, Quinn, to the last storm, Riley, could cause additional strain on liquefied natural gas storage resources in Canaport and Everett. Everett storage tanks currently hold 2.42 Bcf, and Canaport has 6.89 Bcf, each about half-empty,” the firm said. While power outages will likely “scrub out some demand,” the ongoing outage at the 680 MW Pilgrim nuclear plant in Massachusetts could prove bullish for natural gas demand, adding a potential 116 MMcf/d.

Algonquin Citygate shed 43 cents to average $3.77, while Transco Zone 6 New York gave up 30 cents to $2.79.

In Appalachia, Dominion South added 10 cents to average $2.40, while Columbia Gas added a penny to $2.51.

“Structural demand in the Appalachian region is on pace to register its second winter of growth, and one of its largest winter-on-winter gains since Winter 2013/14,” Genscape told clients Thursday. “Although there are more than 20 days left this winter, winter-to-date weather-normalized demand in Appalachia is on pace to average 13.6 Bcf/d. If realized, that will mark a 0.61 Bcf/d gain from last winter’s weather-normalized levels, and sustains a trend that has been in the works for many years.”

Structural demand in the region has increased seven of the past nine winters, according to the firm, with the largest gains occurring in the power burn sector.

“The gains have been facilitated by new pipeline infrastructure to move regional production growth into demand markets to serve load growth, fuel switching in the residential heating space and fuel switching in the power sector,” Genscape said.

In the West, spot prices sold off by double digits across the Rockies and California amid warmer temperatures throughout much of the region, but NWS was calling for snowfall Friday in higher elevations in the Pacific Northwest and northern Rockies.

“Temperatures across the West will generally be somewhat above normal given the influx of Pacific air across the region,” NWS said Thursday. “The remainder of the country is expected to be dry and relatively mild with temperatures generally above normal. This will especially be the case across the central and southern High Plains, where temperatures will be as much as 10-20 degrees above normal.”

Genscape was forecasting demand in California and Nevada to total 5.96 Bcf/d Friday and around 5.3 Bcf/d over the weekend. That’s versus demand of 6.66 Bcf/d Thursday and a recent seven-day average of 7.57 Bcf/d.

Malin tumbled 23 cents to $2.18, while SoCal Citygate dropped 17 cents to $2.80 and SoCal Border Average gave up 17 cents to $2.27.

Further upstream in the Rockies, most points dropped around 20 cents, including Opal, which fell 20 cents to $2.18. It was a similar story in West Texas, where El Paso Permian gave up 24 cents to $1.83.